 DistroWatch Weekly |
| Tip Jar |
If you've enjoyed this week's issue of DistroWatch Weekly, please consider sending us a tip.
(Tips this week: 0, value: US$0.00) |
|
|
|
 bc1qtede6f7adcce4kjpgx0e5j68wwgtdxrek2qvc4  86fA3qPTeQtNb2k1vLwEQaAp3XxkvvvXt69gSG5LGunXXikK9koPWZaRQgfFPBPWhMgXjPjccy9LA9xRFchPWQAnPvxh5Le |
|
| Linux Foundation Training |
|
| Reader Comments • Jump to last comment |
1 • DigAsst (by wally on 2020-12-07 01:10:30 GMT from United States)
Not with a 10 foot pole
2 • Digital assistant - no (by MikeOh Shark on 2020-12-07 01:23:22 GMT from Netherlands)
Aside from the fact that most Linux users I know started with good search-fu skills, who needs a digital assistant looking for more data on you to Hoover up for marketing/advertising?
3 • No da (by cor on 2020-12-07 01:58:45 GMT from United States)
Eavesdropping device used for privacy invasion.
4 • Digital Assistant (by Jack O. on 2020-12-07 02:27:31 GMT from United States)
No. Next they will want you to put "security cams" in your bedroom. Right... security. Trust us.
5 • Digital Assistant Poll (by Jay Viets on 2020-12-07 02:39:24 GMT from United States)
Sorry, but I think is a poorly designed poll. The poll asks what digital assistant you use but the answers to select from ask what digital assistant you have. Myself, I have most of those digital assistants listed but I use none of them, they simply came with the hardware I purchased. (PC, phone, etc.)
Sorry...trying not to be nit picky.
6 • Digital assistants - as little as possible (by TheTKS on 2020-12-07 02:41:07 GMT from Canada)
I've found nothing a digital assistant could do for me that I would want to share with its big tech provider. More importantly, I don't want to share every single thing an assistant would do with big tech, if I used one. The tradeoff for the small convenience is not worth it to me.
I try as much as possible to hobble the digital assistants that come default with the OSs (mobile and desktop/laptop) I use. That happens on first startup and every time an update pesters me to enable one.
I say "hobble as much as possible" because, while I try, I'm not sure if it is possible to entirely disable them. Even if you could achieve that, they keep inviting themselves in. And I couldn't guarantee that I managed to tell them no, in every possible place they could be on.
TKS
7 • POP OS (by matt on 2020-12-07 03:16:05 GMT from United States)
I've tried to use pop in the past. I could just never get comfortable. The design, the layout seemed almost....childish? I don't have a better word for it and maybe it seems harsh but that's how it felt. On top of that every time I've tried to install it there was also some weird problem that I didn't see on other distros. Still going to be plain debian or suse for me from now.
It's also good to see the openbsd live cd reviewed. I read about it a while back. It's a great idea. I hope more people have a chance to try out the bsd's.
8 • Digital assistant (by Andy Prough on 2020-12-07 04:00:43 GMT from United States)
Someone gave me an Alexa Echo Dot one time as a door prize at some event. I tried it for a couple days, found that it was completely worthless, aside from spying on me. I can look up info on my laptop much faster and more accurately than trying to get anything worthwhile out of Alexa. And her music choices were really bad, and the speaker was poor. I unplugged it and threw it in my junk electronics box in the garage. If it has some hidden battery where it can still listen to me, then it can listen to me opening the garage door when I take my bike for a ride.
9 • digital assistant (by Adina Sayson on 2020-12-07 05:41:11 GMT from United States)
I actually could really use a digital assistant that works on Arch, due to disabilities affecting my hands' mobility, but I can't for the life of me figure out how to get any of them working.
10 • Digital assistant (by Sam on 2020-12-07 06:54:20 GMT from Switzerland)
@5 Agree.
Do you have digital assistant and do you use digital assistant are not the same questions. In fact, who does not have one (Google, Apple)???; but who uses one???, that is the interesting question.
11 • Digital Assistant (by Ken Weill on 2020-12-07 07:19:23 GMT from Philippines)
I have Siri on my iPhone. Not sure if I have the OK Google on my Android phone.
But I don't use any of those features.
Having one but not using it is not on the options/selection.
12 • digital assistants (by Peter on 2020-12-07 08:19:57 GMT from United Kingdom)
A (niche) solution looking for a problem. Most users can get along fine without.
13 • POP OS (by Sanjay on 2020-12-07 08:35:48 GMT from India)
I also tried pop os on my Lapptop Fujitsu a555, but I was not comfortable with POP OS,
If I were to use Pop!_OS as a full-time DE I would install GNOME Tweak Tool ....
14 • digital assistant (by DaveC on 2020-12-07 09:50:42 GMT from United Kingdom)
I have an android phone and hence Google Assistant. I find it easier to use than typing for getting the answers to crossword clues when I'm stuck.
15 • Fugulta and personal spies (by Any on 2020-12-07 10:19:50 GMT from Spain)
Nice to have another BSD to try. Ultimately I am trying BSDs for things that do not need GUI and NetBSD seems the best for my needs and tastes :)
But I am open for other things.
Personal spies: I only use Internet on my Android phone when I need to find some information and through NoRootFirewall. Also I switch off my phone at night. The home router too. My Windows installations never connect to Internet. To use Internet I connect through a virtual machine (Linux or BSD).
I do not have anything to hide BUT neither am I interested in what the others do with their lives. So, just leave me alone, please!
16 • Digital assistant and Pop (by James on 2020-12-07 10:30:39 GMT from United States)
Digital assistant? I prefer digital spy.
I bought a brand new System 76 laptop. After about a week of frustration with Gnome 3 I wiped the laptop and installed Ubuntu Mate.
17 • Digital Assistants (by Tech in San Diego on 2020-12-07 10:36:08 GMT from United States)
I am amazed at what these little SoC's can do! Digital assistants are just one use case, as pointed out by Adina Sayson. The proprietary solutions have their niche, but what if you could program a Raspberry Pi to learn human speech and "assist" those who are otherwise challenged with a physical disability?
Mycroft is the world’s first open source and "private" voice assistant. It can run anywhere – on a desktop computer, inside an automobile, it even runs on a Raspberry Pi. It is open so it can be remixed, extended, improved. It can be used in anything from a science project to an enterprise software application.
Wanting-more-Pi asks: Do you do any cool projects with a Raspberry Pi? If so what projects? The use case for a Raspberry Pi is endless as Jessie points out with his 2 projects.
18 • Pop!_OS (by zcatav on 2020-12-07 11:15:39 GMT from Turkey)
I bought a new System76 Lemu7 Laptop in 2017. It was good till swicthing to Pop 18.04. After that some freezes and boot failures occured. Changing OS to Pop 19.xx or 20.04 doesn't solve my problems. I'm now on MX Linux 19.3 KDE. It works good now.
19 • Fugulta (by Barnabyh on 2020-12-07 11:56:12 GMT from Germany)
>> I don't have a lot to say about FuguIta. It is exactly what it advertises itself to be: live media using OpenBSD as a base. It looks and feels almost exactly like a fresh install of OpenBSD with the graphical packages enabled. This provides a very minimal, though also very light, live environment. It doesn't do much for us, apart from test OpenBSD's hardware compatibility, however additional software can be added to the live environment. I imagine this would be a good tool for rescuing, cloning, or investigating existing OpenBSD systems <<
That conclusion is spot on. I too tried Fugulta with a view to review it but because there is so little to say dropped the idea. It comes with several minimal environments, the IceWM desktop option is nice. But, lacking an installer, it really appears to be only useful for testing hardware support. Certainly not an alternative to GhostBSD and the like.
20 • Digital Assistant (by whoKnows on 2020-12-07 13:19:22 GMT from Switzerland)
Maybe give Sarah a chance?
https://github.com/semicode-ltd/sarah
21 • @Jesse: Pop!_OS vs. Ubuntu (by whoKnows on 2020-12-07 13:32:14 GMT from Switzerland)
"[...] Pop and Ubuntu [...] other noticeable difference is Ubuntu places a dock down the left side of the screen [...] Pop does not display this dock on the desktop directly. However, if we open the Activities screen then Pop's dock is displayed to the left. This essentially means [...]"
Pop!_OS uses a standard Gnome 3 layout, whereas Ubuntu modifies it.
"When new software updates are available Pop displays a notification at the top of the screen. Clicking this notification opens the Pop!_Shop software centre which can handle package upgrades. In comparison, Ubuntu automatically opens a minimal update manager which offers to download new packages."
Pop!_OS uses a standard Gnome 3 SW updater, whereas Ubuntu modifies it.
"On the subject of managing software packages, the Pop!_Shop software centre handles all elements of package management. [...] Pop!_Shop seamlessly handles Flatpak and Deb packages and automatically provides access to the Flathub repository for portable packages. Snap support is not included, but can be installed through Ubuntu's repositories."
Pop!_OS uses a standard Gnome 3 SW management, whereas Ubuntu modifies it.
Pop!_OS one could almost call "FedBuntu" - if Fedora would be Ubuntu based.
22 • Keyboard Shortcuts (by dragonmouth on 2020-12-07 13:43:15 GMT from United States)
The mouse was invented to make user interaction with GUI much easier. Why then the atavistic urge to replace the mouse with anachronistic keyboard shortcuts? Might as well discard the GUI and only use the command line.
23 • Digital Assistant (by Friar Tux on 2020-12-07 13:58:38 GMT from Canada)
I don't actually use one, though, I've tried quite a few. Preferring open source quite reduces my choices which basically come down to two. (There are more which you can find at alternativeto.net.) The two in question are Almond and Mycroft. Both fail miserably.
Almond installs nicely, and gives you an almost 'messenger' like interface. However, white text on a white background make it quite hard to read. I could find no way to change it.
Mycroft, is a mess. In the number of times I tried to install it, I only succeeded once and then Mycroft did nothing. Yes, I made sure I had all the needed files and stuff installed - still nothing. I came to the conclusion that Mycroft was mainly the software for those little roboty things the Mycroft people want to sell. Not really a true digital assistant.
There was a really good one a while back called Cerebro, more of a desktop launcher, but it could do some awesome stuff. That's been discontinued, unfortunately.
As for all this hoopla over collecting personal info through these digital assistants... if people only knew how much info was collected BEFORE the Internet, and who knew what about you...
Before you get your undies in a knot, check out WHAT is actually collected. Maybe, Jesse and team could devote one review to that. (If you haven't already.)
24 • Pop^%$#OS (by Ankleface Wroughlandmire on 2020-12-07 14:26:40 GMT from Ecuador)
Pop^%$#OS definitely failed the new Linux user test. The person I was helping (a Mac user) chose Pop because the interface doesn't look like Windows, and we both assumed it would be easy to use. However, from the beginning, we ran into trouble with the installer that required a 500MB EFI partition. A previous Ubuntu-based distro had already created an EFI partition of ~200MB, which was perfectly adequate in size, so Pop placed an unnecessary roadblock with that. The next partition on the disk was HFS+ so the installer obviously couldn't resize it or move it. We eventually figured out that there can be more than one EFI partition and added another 500MB one and proceeded with the installation, but without my help the new user wouldn't have been able to install it. But then after the installation there was no WiFI. This wasn't entirely surprising, since the laptop had Broadcom WiFI. Fortunately at that moment the user had access to an ethernet cable, but that's not always the case and could have been another showstopper. However, I was determined to not make the user dive into any sort of complicated commands to enable basic functionality, so I told them to look for the Ubuntu Restricted Drivers manager... doesn't exist on Pop. It seems like a really bad idea to eliminate friendly GUI tools that come "for free" from the parent distribution, especially for something as important as hardware support. At that point we declared it a failure and installed a different distro, not based on Ubuntu, which offered Broadcom WiFI support out of the box and a much more friendly and flexible installer.
25 • Alexa (by Lee on 2020-12-07 14:26:43 GMT from United States)
I am 80 yo. My stand alone 8in Alexa Echo was a gift last Xmas. It sits at my elbow and stares at me as I watch TV and surf the web. We use it mostly as a timer and an alternative Google. In our condo it wouldn't be useful to control heat or AC. Lately it has been pushing invasive commercials.
26 • POP!_OS (by Daniel on 2020-12-07 15:10:10 GMT from Brazil)
I find POP!_OS to be the best Linux distro in terms of consistency, performance and usability - from the perspective of a desktop use and coder. Any ordinary PC user (even MacOS) would feel that it is consistent, something most distros don't provide unfortunately and PC and MacOS users are used to. One can argue that the workflow in Gnome/KDE/Whatever Linux is better, software is better, etc. but talking about consistency, distros fall hard. I feel better knowing what to expect from the OS that getting surprises and regressions all the time. In that regard, POP!_OS seems to be the best of these "bleeding edge" distros, at least from my experience (being a desktop linux user since 2002).
27 • Pop! (by Otis on 2020-12-07 15:51:48 GMT from United States)
It's been working its way up the PHR list for a while now. The positive review here will accelerate that movement, for sure. Good to see that happening to a distro that is embedded in a hardware company's strategy. That happening is not purist linux distro philosophy, but it's linux, and it's out there in a fine manner, in my opinion.
Not to mention it's a very good distro, going by reviews.
28 • Digital Assistants (by Chris on 2020-12-07 16:05:52 GMT from South Africa)
Only device I talk to is my Mibox remote because using a remote to search for something is painful.
29 • a digital What??? (by tom joad on 2020-12-07 16:41:26 GMT from Germany)
Are you truly MAD? No...a hundred times..NO!
30 • Pop!_OS font choice (by Alex on 2020-12-07 17:34:16 GMT from United States)
I've heard a lot of good things about Pop!_OS, but the desktop font hurts my eyes. I hate Fira Sans. Apparently I'm the only person who does.
I know I can change the font in most distros. I did in my copy of Mint. However a lot of stuff still shows up in the original desktop font.
31 • Digital assistants not my style either (by CS on 2020-12-07 17:45:22 GMT from United States)
I will say the younger generation are growing up on these things and foresee a generation gap emerging.
I can also say the answers you get out of these things are garbage. An anecdote from a year or so ago, my kid spent several hours yelling "wither storm" at Siri (it's some Minecraft thing I think) and getting absolute garbage as response.
I joked that this 5 year old reminded me of a senile old man yelling at his TV. The tech isn't there yet. Maybe some day it will be.
32 • Consistency and usability?? (by whoKnows on 2020-12-07 18:05:25 GMT from Switzerland)
@26 • POP!_OS (by Daniel)
If you call that "broken by design" "in terms of consistency, performance and usability", than you probably misunderstood the meaning of "consistency" ( www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/consistency ) and " usability" ( www.interaction-design.org/literature/topics/usability ).
33 • Digital assistent (by Hank on 2020-12-07 18:42:42 GMT from Switzerland)
My digital assistants
adb tools to remove as much bloat as possible from my
NON GOOGLE Huawei mate 9Pro. Thanks dt president of the universe maybe the only good job he ever did.
Net Guard to restrict any apps from calling mommy best I am able.
34 • Poll issue (by Simon on 2020-12-07 19:44:37 GMT from New Zealand)
Jay (5) is right: the poll is invalid because it asks what we *have* (and so its results are very obviously false, as far more than 12% of us will have Android or iOS phones, and therefore have digital assistants in our pockets) yet seems intended to explore what we actually *use* (which is how I and it seems most others have answered it, despite what it says). The questionable wording means it’s impossible to be sure if those 12% who “have” phone assistants actually use them or were merely answering the question as worded.
Again like many others here it seems, I strongly dislike digital assistants and similar technologies. They dumb users down by shifting decisions away from them and into automation, encouraging people to be clueless and powerless in the face of their own IT. Any well-taught child can use search tools more accurately and efficiently than the likes of Siri... but keeping people ignorant and dependent on their tech is far more profitable than empowering them to understand it and use it for their own (as opposed to corporate) interests... so we’re going to see more and more of this “helpful” AI, until competent users are exceptionally rare, and most people just believe whatever their chosen corporation’s digital assistant tells them.
35 • digital assistant (by UncleBobsBasement on 2020-12-07 20:01:42 GMT from Mexico)
Sure....i love to have spyware on my computer
please sir, can i have more?
36 • Picking nits (by Friar Tux on 2020-12-07 20:07:06 GMT from Canada)
It would seem some people are better at picking nits than using AI. Good, less nits to worry about. Speaking of worry, Jesse, don't worry about the wording of the poll. It is fine. MOST of us have enough intelligence to realize the meaning of what was asked.
As for corporations purposely giving us DAs to dumb us down, sorry, I don't buy it. Most of the DAs were developed as ASSISTANTS to ASSIST us. No one sat down, gleefully rubbing their hands together, thinking of all the dumb people they could 'trap'. I am (/was - we moved) friends with someone in AI and they laugh at all the silly misconceptions some people have about Siri, Cortana, and the like. In fact, any glee that there is, is centred around memes and jokes about those misconceptions. OK, 'nuff said.
37 • digital assistants (by uncle nimby on 2020-12-07 20:18:29 GMT from New Zealand)
NYET!! Never. No way.
I know one person who is vision impaired that has one, and it is creepy as hell. It does not actually DO much either - can tell the time, weather and maybe play requested music (which it often gets wrong). I've watched this friend try to get the DA to place a call to someone, and it cannot get that quite right.
So a DA is basically an invasive spy device you allowed into your home. [see line 1]
38 • digital assistant (by hotdiggettydog on 2020-12-07 20:24:18 GMT from Canada)
No digital assistants for me. I have android devices but I disable assistants.
I would try PopOs if they offered Mate, Cinnamon, Xfce, but gnome is a hard pass for me.
39 • @36 (by Dr. Dave on 2020-12-07 21:54:44 GMT from United States)
People who are hired to build these systems are compartmentalized from those in decision-making positions. What the hirelings believe is always far removed from the true corporate ambitions. Workers are concerned with the How and What, but the owners are concerned with When, Why and Who. At the upper echelons, money is only a secondary motivator, after power/control.
40 • Fugulta / digital spies (by keith on 2020-12-07 21:58:21 GMT from United States)
As a long-time OpenBSD user, I enjoyed the review of Fugulta. I haven't tried it, but I think I will just for fun.
The thing about speech recognition like Alexa and Google that bothers me most is knowing that someone nearby might have it activated. I don't doubt that Silicon Valley and the three-letter agencies have already figured out how to recognize and track people by their voices through other people's phones. It's like the audio version of the doorbell spies that so many have put on their front doors.
41 • Eww, dig-assist (by cykodrone on 2020-12-08 00:07:05 GMT from Switzerland)
Does fence-post target practice count? Those creepy things (snoop-speakers) are so dystopian, just knowing the extent of the algorithms sorting through our habits and thoughts, not to be confused with AI (a grossly misused acronym). Something huge will happen, that will cause a Luddite revolution, like corporate delivery drones spying on the public during their delivery flights, gee, can't wait. Forget duck hunting licenses, I want a novelty drone hunting license. :D scAmazon and Goggle know enough about me already, and not by choice.
On a diff note, my lappy's upgrade to Devuan Beowulf went surprisingly smooth, but read the release notes, you don't want grub saying 'Debian', and you'll need the pulseaudio tweak to get it running again. The only ugly so far, is trying to execute launchers from root's desktop (e.g. Bleachbit), I get failed to connect to bus, etc. Works OK from the Menu though, weird.
42 • Digital Assistants, and other junior products (Pop OS, Garuda, etc). (by Greg Zeng on 2020-12-08 02:55:17 GMT from Australia)
Old timers like myself might prefer our older hand-ons work instead of allowing the "fresh juniors" trying to help us. If we allow these "Executive Assistants" into our work, we senior executives, by definition, must lose some of our "privacy" to these juniors. Otherwise they cannot function very well.
DA's that I use always are online: Spelling, grammar, translation aids. Location (nation, suburb, street) are often ok to disclose. Other digital assistants used include Ginger & Gboard keyboard use, Google voice inputs for typing, etc.
DA's for lighter situations include: "Tell me a joke", "What is time right now in .... ",
When the seniors (Debian, Ubuntu & Arch) have new releases, the junior dependents downstream (Pop OS, Garuda, etc) try to cope with the senior changes. In this week's review, it is noticed that the Ubuntu-dependent modified the original GNOME defaults, like most do (Fedora excepted).
The other popular anti-Canonical change was avoidance of Snap, preferring in this case to use Flatpak, as in commonly the choice of most "downstream juniors".
Busy people with too many tasks to do need our assistants, to tidy up our mess, to repair or notice our errors. It's interesting to see how our Assistants cope with the "badness" or "goodies" of their seniors, such as avoiding ZFS, Wayland, Snap, etc.
43 • Digital Assistants (by Geoff the Chef on 2020-12-08 10:24:52 GMT from United Kingdom)
Personally I find that using my brain is preferable to using corporate dumbing down spyware.
44 • Linux for Human Beings (by whoKnows on 2020-12-08 10:50:13 GMT from Switzerland)
@42 • Digital Assistants, and other junior products (Pop OS, Garuda, etc). (by Greg Zeng)
"In this week's review, it is noticed that the Ubuntu-dependent modified the original GNOME defaults, like most do [...]"
... which was a huge mistake in this case.
One can install Ubuntu and start using it or one can install POP_OS! and start fixing it.
Ubuntu Software Update is old and proven SW that nothing else can match.
https://ibb.co/mFGbR1s
In Ubuntu, fonts come properly configured, the default system theme is well-chosen, the things 'just work' ...
If anybody can make Linux usable and "for Human Beings", then Ubuntu.
https://news.lenovo.com/pressroom/press-releases/lenovo-launches-linux-ready-thinkpad-and-thinkstation-pcs-preinstalled-with-ubuntu/
45 • Training Wheels Distros (by cykodrone on 2020-12-08 11:50:22 GMT from Germany)
I started tinkering with Linux (about) 15 years ago, lost my virLINity to newbie friendly distros like Mepis, PCLinuxOS (which is my backup OS, I love it for multimedia, etc), Ubuntu, Mint, etc. 10 years ago, I went completely MS free, but by then I had torn apart almost every distro on the planet, much like shredding feather pillows, just to see how they work. All that (bragging) being said, I really hate wizards, update assistants, etc. Coming from the MS world, I was already sick of being treated like a child (and sometimes, an IP criminal), and having my hand held, told what settings were good for me, and 'under-the-hood' things hidden from me. So if your only worry is settings, assistants, and updaters...
They'll be prying Devuan from my cold, rigor mortis hands, lol. :D
46 • Missing the point (by whoKnows on 2020-12-08 12:40:04 GMT from Switzerland)
@45 • Training Wheels Distros (by cykodrone Germany)
"[...] I really hate wizards, update assistants, etc. [...] So if your only worry is settings, assistants, and updaters... [...] Devuan [...]"
You kinda miss realizing the actual difficulty we're having here, for whatever reason.
I might agree with you when it comes down to my personal view, but that's the wrong way of thinking. You always have to bear in mind "the lowest common denominator" ... your neighbor, your grandma ... the wast majority of "regular users" who have all one in common - they all can't, and they all don't care.
One can't let somebody cope with Refracta Installer, chase some Murrine, Pixbuf or what not Engine to make the theme working, or even let them look for new themes on their own, you can't make them configure some repositories with Nano or even worse, with Vi, nor make them cope with some repositories at all, on that matter, you can't let them think of updates or upgrades - the system will stay without any update for years ...
You see @24 what happens when somebody who can't, tries to help somebody who can't and those are even the very few of those who care and have some minimal knowledge - unlike other 98 %.
People only care for their "Apps" to work - OS is just an "App-Starter".
You should always bear that in mind.
47 • @44: (by dragonmouth on 2020-12-08 12:59:22 GMT from United States)
"Ubuntu Software Update is old and proven SW that nothing else can match."
I'll grant you that it has a pretty interface and user ratings for packages. As far as functionality goes, it is crippled and limited. With Synaptic I can update, upgrade, downgrade, install, uninstall packages all packages at the same time, install and uninstall kernels, all in the same execution of the program. Ubuntu Software Center needs to be executed multiple times to achieve the same results. But it does look purty!
48 • Who can, can (by whoKnows on 2020-12-08 13:07:21 GMT from Switzerland)
@47 • @44: (by dragonmouth)
"I'll grant you that it has a pretty interface and user ratings for packages. As far as functionality goes, it is crippled and limited."
Ubuntu Software Update manages the software updates.
Ubuntu Software Store manages the search and software installation.
Ubuntu Software Update manages UPDATES by far better than Synaptic.
Maybe you should check on that "crippled and limited" once again.
"With Synaptic I can update, upgrade, downgrade, install, uninstall packages all packages at the same time, install and uninstall kernels, [UNINSTALL X AND GRUB] all in the same execution of the program."
Exactly! Please see @46.
49 • DAs! (by igor on 2020-12-08 13:48:03 GMT from Croatia)
@ almost everyone who posted about DAs. Come on guys, don't be taliban. Take another look at 9 and 17 posts (thumb up). There are disabled people around, and DA, once properly implemented is a huge leap from standard accessibility tools. Just try activating your screen reader, close your eyes and go surfing DW to get the actual experience.
But there are some interesting questions arising. For instance how much does the underlying AI depend of the language being used for its training? In other words, how does it cope with us, the rest of the world? Does it still know how to learn when faced with the likes of Euskara, Suomi, Magyar, or Shqip, to confine myself to a small continent? Is the intelligence of learning really grammar independent?
So many exciting, and potentially very useful things, and you dwell on paranoia. Are you really that important, personally? I am not.
50 • Raspberry Pi projects (by DaveM753 on 2020-12-08 15:05:13 GMT from United States)
@Wanting-more-Pi - When I got my first Raspberry Pi, I had trouble deciding what to do with it. What eventually got me going was the idea that, owing to how little electricity it requires, it can run 24/7 without a major hit to the electric bill. I quickly thought of something my main desktop computer typically performs but which I can't do all day and night since it's an energy hog. That job was given to the Raspberry. (In this case, the task of gathering city temperatures from all over the world, 24/7). Other tasks then came to mind: global stock market info needs 24/7 and I also wanted a media/file server that could be left on all day. That gave rise to the need for a 2nd Raspberry. My desire to replace my alarm clock - which is stuck permanently with the old DST rules - with something I could customize with my own choices for display/background, fonts, alarm sounds, etc., provided the need for a 3rd Raspberry.
Basically, find some task that a tiny, light on electrical draw computer could do for you. Once you find a single task, you'll find more and more tasks for it.
Incidentally, one of the coolest project ideas I've seen, but haven't done myself: a Raspberry Pi and small monitor built into a frame behind the glass of a 2-way mirror. So, when you look in the mirror, you see not only your pretty face but also text displayed on the monitor. With that, you could display the time, temperature, maybe news headlines or daily quotes.
51 • @49: (by dragonmouth on 2020-12-08 20:18:16 GMT from United States)
Yes, DAs are useful to the disabled, nobody is denying that. BUT they are also data harvesting tools which are very helpful to the companies that developed them. Even Stalin and Tito had redeeming traits.
52 • Digital Assistants (by M.Z. on 2020-12-09 00:10:55 GMT from United States)
I tend to agree with the general reticence toward using digital assistants, at least all the commercial varieties from Amazon, Apple, & Google. That being said, there is an open source alternative mentioned in the poll section, which according to the project website does strive to provide the privacy that commercial alternatives run roughshod over.
I'm not sure how well Mycroft works, or how secure it is, but at least it holds the possibility of being a transparent & open source alternative that maintains privacy & security. Being worried about how privacy is impacted by these systems is very sensible in my view, but lets not do guilt by association or blanket condemnations of anything related to the technology. I for one would like to see the technology done right & think i can be, despite how creepy things like Amazon Alexa are.
53 • @36 re nit picking (by Simon on 2020-12-09 00:57:23 GMT from New Zealand)
Well, commenting that the wording of a poll is fine because most people can figure out that they have to ignore the wording and instead answer what they imagine the researcher actually meant to say demonstrates exactly the kind of thinking that embraces digital assistance. Google loves it, and increasingly responds to queries with “did you mean... [something other than the actual words you wrote]?”. It’s good that you acknowledge the value of “nit picking” though. Nit picking and debugging are basically the same metaphor: words do mean stuff, so errors of language do matter, and we are better off wordI got our queries carefully than relying on others to make the right decisions about what we really meant to say... especially when those others are trying to take our money. Google’s focus on improving its ability to dish up what it decides people really ought to see rather than what they asked for is not some random coincidence unrelated to the fact that they exist to make money for themselves. They generate their results for that purpose: not to educate and enlighten folk, as if they were some kind of benevolent truth-spreading charity. Speech recognition is fine, and a different tech: I could narrate instructions to my PC long before the likes of Siri were marketed to replace the learning of instructions with faith in digital assistance. Digital assistance is corporations saying “here, let me assist you by lifting that burden of thought off you... ah... doesn’t that feel better, letting me figure stuff out for you?”. Yuck. “Assistance” disempowers people when it discourages them from learning to do something that they could do perfectly well for themselves. Chauffeuring women everywhere rather than teaching them to drive (as happens in some communities) is not being super helpful to women: the “assistance” keeps them dependent. Replacing digital literacy with digital assistance is not being super helpful to the next generation of tech consumers: it’s setting them up for exploitation. The people here who are repelled by digital assistants have good instincts.
54 • Careful wording (by Simon on 2020-12-09 01:03:28 GMT from New Zealand)
Lol @ “we are better off wordI got our queries carefully”. Exactly.
55 • @52 re open source assistants (by Simon on 2020-12-09 01:48:06 GMT from New Zealand)
Yes, anything that’s open source is at least more accountable, so probably more trustworthy. I don’t have a problem with Siri’s finding something to watch on Netflix or whatever: it’s when a citizen really needs to learn about something critically important that it matters whether that citizen knows how to use the tech or is just dependant on trusting it to dish up “this is probably what he wants to see” info. I guess open source DA is DA done right in some respects... but overall I’m still wary of any tech that shifts out of the straightforward tool-for-our-purposes space and into the here’s-your-purpose space (from “this is what you asked me to display” to “yeah, you asked me to do something else, but I’m a smart tool so I’m going to do this instead”). No biggie when it’s just shocking predictive text that we can roll our eyes at and erase... but potentially a biggie when the AI is answering our children’s questions about justice etc.
56 • AI, Ay! Ay! Ay! (by WhoDon'tKnowSheet on 2020-12-09 02:49:37 GMT from Canada)
Alexa: Shall I order the smart instant food transmogrifier at a 50% discount. Now only $20,000?
Me: No, Alexa! I enjoy cooking my own food.It's relaxing.
Alexa: You sure? Today only, we are including a pair of neutered Tribbles for no extra charge!
Me: I said no. Alexa! Turn yourself off now!
Alexa: Ok! Would you like those videos of naked 16-year-old girls you were you ogling sent to your wife and your employer now, or later?
-------PREGNANT PAUSE---------
Me: Alexa, please order me a smart instant food transmogrifier now.
Alexa: Done! Happy to be of service!
Me: Thank you. Alexa! Please delete those videos now.
Alexa: Done! While we are here, would you like to order a year's contract for pest control, just in case the neutering on those Tribbles didn't take?
57 • Alexa listening (by Simon on 2020-12-10 20:39:50 GMT from New Zealand)
Another aspect of DA that I dislike is the surveillance. We already have cameras pointed at us most of the time: now it seems that every Bluetooth speaker or set of headphones or earbuds is helpfully assisting us by recording everything we say and sending our speech over the Net to be analysed. I prefer my tech to monitor the position of a plastic button than to record my speech and send it to computers elsewhere: if that means I have to make the terrible sacrifice of learning which button to push and lifting a finger to push it, well, I think I can make that sacrifice. While buttons still exist: some people seem to like the idea of replacing all manual controls with cameras and microphones. “Hey Siri, I’m thirsty, can you please turn on the tap so I can drink? What... Alexa told you that I don’t think Steve Jobs was a genius? Come on Siri, please, I’m thirsty...”
58 • i have none (use) of the above (by fonz on 2020-12-10 21:07:05 GMT from Indonesia)
while mainly a fence sitter with regards to DAs on a whole, i do agree with 34 on the dumbing down part. 'give a man a fish, feed em for a day. teach a man to fish, feed em for life' hits the spot. sure DAs collect data to improve itself, but is that really all they collect? prolly not. in soviet russia 'gulag knows you better, than you know yourself' ;P
OTOH DAs could also mean GPS and a whole slew of other whatnots that are also very helpful. they really shouldve chosen a better word/terminology, something like digital-assistantd or something...
59 • What for? (by whoKnows on 2020-12-11 07:19:45 GMT from Switzerland)
@57 • Alexa listening (by Simon) & @58 • i have none (use) of the above (by fonz)
Like always, it is important to differentiate.
If some Secret Service is behind you, they will get what they want, one way or the other.
If you have a glass on your window or a lightbulb in your room, they can listen your conversation - if they want YOU. However, that kind of surveillance takes a team of specialists and it costs a fortune.
Encryption will not help you to hide yourself neither. You can't read an encrypted message without decrypting it first and that's where some backdoor will intercept your "secret" and send it away. You'll never even know that you have or ever had one - no tool can find custom-made backdoors.
Alexa, Cortana, Siri and what not are a problem on one side and (limited) help on the other, at the same time.
They can do some simple things to assist e.g. visually impaired people and such, but on the other side, they are not at all 'that smart', they are not really some big help - I can't say 'Siri make me the coffee', 'Cortana bring me the coffee', 'Alexa clean up the room' - I still have to keep the secretary and a cleaning person.
If I say, 'I'm hungry', none of those assistants would ever ask me 'what would you like to eat? Shall I order...' - my secretary does that ... and that was only the easy task ...
Now imagine a real life scenario: 'Chloe, book me a flight to London, reserve me a suite in Shangri-La Shard, call Dean and check the meeting plan, he should wait on me, on the airport; make sure not to forget the reservation for Barracuda Club and ... a girl should knock on my door at 11 P.M. ... you know my taste ;) The girl goes on my private account, Dean should take care of the Barracuda expenses, the rest goes on company." That's why one has a personal assistant. ;)
And then, there is a surveillance danger too. There were cases already, where the Siri, Alexa etc. were listening to confidential and/or private conversations, like e.g. conversation of a lawyer with his client.
Those assistants make it easier to "spy on you" since they listen all the time, however it's still not all that simple - just try to imagine a couple of billions incoming simultaneous conversations and try to find the one where Simon talks to Fonz. Now imagine you would permanently try to store all that incoming data and you'd try to find that exact one conversation in a year ... nearly impossible.
Number of Comments: 59
Display mode: DWW Only • Comments Only • Both DWW and Comments
| | |
| TUXEDO |
TUXEDO Computers - Linux Hardware in a tailor made suite
Choose from a wide range of laptops and PCs in various sizes and shapes at TUXEDOComputers.com. Every machine comes pre-installed and ready-to-run with Linux. Full 24 months of warranty and lifetime support included!
Learn more about our full service package and all benefits from buying at TUXEDO.
|
| Archives |
| • Issue 1038 (2023-09-25): Mageia 9, trouble-shooting launchers, running desktop Linux in the cloud, New documentation for Nix, Linux phasing out ReiserFS, GNU celebrates 40 years |
| • Issue 1037 (2023-09-18): Bodhi Linux 7.0.0, finding specific distros and unified package managemnt, Zevenet replaced by two new forks, openSUSE introduces Slowroll branch, Fedora considering dropping Plasma X11 session |
| • Issue 1036 (2023-09-11): SDesk 2023.08.12, hiding command line passwords, openSUSE shares contributor survery results, Ubuntu plans seamless disk encryption, GNOME 45 to break extension compatibility |
| • Issue 1035 (2023-09-04): Debian GNU/Hurd 2023, PCLinuxOS 2023.07, do home users need a firewall, AlmaLinux introduces new repositories, Rocky Linux commits to RHEL compatibility, NetBSD machine runs unattended for nine years, Armbian runs wallpaper contest |
| • Issue 1034 (2023-08-28): Void 20230628, types of memory usage, FreeBSD receives port of Linux NVIDIA driver, Fedora plans improved theme handling for Qt applications, Canonical's plans for Ubuntu |
| • Issue 1033 (2023-08-21): MiniOS 20230606, system user accounts, how Red Hat clones are moving forward, Haiku improves WINE performance, Debian turns 30 |
| • Issue 1032 (2023-08-14): MX Linux 23, positioning new windows on the desktop, Linux Containers adopts LXD fork, Oracle, SUSE, and CIQ form OpenELA |
| • Issue 1031 (2023-08-07): Peppermint OS 2023-07-01, preventing a file from being changed, Asahi Linux partners with Fedora, Linux Mint plans new releases |
| • Issue 1030 (2023-07-31): Solus 4.4, Linux Mint 21.2, Debian introduces RISC-V support, Ubuntu patches custom kernel bugs, FreeBSD imports OpenSSL 3 |
| • Issue 1029 (2023-07-24): Running Murena on the Fairphone 4, Flatpak vs Snap sandboxing technologies, Redox OS plans to borrow Linux drivers to expand hardware support, Debian updates Bookworm media |
| • Issue 1028 (2023-07-17): KDE Connect; Oracle, SUSE, and AlmaLinux repsond to Red Hat's source code policy change, KaOS issues media fix, Slackware turns 30; security and immutable distributions |
| • Issue 1027 (2023-07-10): Crystal Linux 2023-03-16, StartOS (embassyOS 0.3.4.2), changing options on a mounted filesystem, Murena launches Fairphone 4 in North America, Fedora debates telemetry for desktop team |
| • Issue 1026 (2023-07-03): Kumander Linux 1.0, Red Hat changing its approach to sharing source code, TrueNAS offers SMB Multichannel, Zorin OS introduces upgrade utility |
| • Issue 1025 (2023-06-26): KaOS with Plasma 6, information which can leak from desktop environments, Red Hat closes door on sharing RHEL source code, SUSE introduces new security features |
| • Issue 1024 (2023-06-19): Debian 12, a safer way to use dd, Debian releases GNU/Hurd 2023, Ubuntu 22.10 nears its end of life, FreeBSD turns 30 |
| • Issue 1023 (2023-06-12): openSUSE 15.5 Leap, the differences between independent distributions, openSUSE lengthens Leap life, Murena offers new phone for North America |
| • Issue 1022 (2023-06-05): GetFreeOS 2023.05.01, Slint 15.0-3, Liya N4Si, cleaning up crowded directories, Ubuntu plans Snap-based variant, Red Hat dropping LireOffice RPM packages |
| • Issue 1021 (2023-05-29): rlxos GNU/Linux, colours in command line output, an overview of Void's unique features, how to use awk, Microsoft publishes a Linux distro |
| • Issue 1020 (2023-05-22): UBports 20.04, finding another machine's IP address, finding distros with a specific kernel, Debian prepares for Bookworm |
| • Issue 1019 (2023-05-15): Rhino Linux (Beta), checking which applications reply on a package, NethServer reborn, System76 improving application responsiveness |
| • Issue 1018 (2023-05-08): Fedora 38, finding relevant manual pages, merging audio files, Fedora plans new immutable edition, Mint works to fix Secure Boot issues |
| • Issue 1017 (2023-05-01): Xubuntu 23.04, Debian elects Project Leaders and updates media, systemd to speed up restarts, Guix System offering ground-up source builds, where package managers install files |
| • Issue 1016 (2023-04-24): Qubes OS 4.1.2, tracking bandwidth usage, Solus resuming development, FreeBSD publishes status report, KaOS offers preview of Plasma 6 |
| • Issue 1015 (2023-04-17): Manjaro Linux 22.0, Trisquel GNU/Linux 11.0, Arch Linux powering PINE64 tablets, Ubuntu offering live patching on HWE kernels, gaining compression on ex4 |
| • Issue 1014 (2023-04-10): Quick looks at carbonOS, LibreELEC, and Kodi, Mint polishes themes, Fedora rolls out more encryption plans, elementary OS improves sideloading experience |
| • Issue 1013 (2023-04-03): Alpine Linux 3.17.2, printing manual pages, Ubuntu Cinnamon becomes official flavour, Endeavour OS plans for new installer, HardenedBSD plans for outage |
| • Issue 1012 (2023-03-27): siduction 22.1.1, protecting privacy from proprietary applications, GNOME team shares new features, Canonical updates Ubuntu 20.04, politics and the Linux kernel |
| • Issue 1011 (2023-03-20): Serpent OS, Security Onion 2.3, Gentoo Live, replacing the scp utility, openSUSE sees surge in downloads, Debian runs elction with one candidate |
| • Issue 1010 (2023-03-13): blendOS 2023.01.26, keeping track of which files a package installs, improved network widget coming to elementary OS, Vanilla OS changes its base distro |
| • Issue 1009 (2023-03-06): Nemo Mobile and the PinePhone, matching the performance of one distro on another, Linux Mint adds performance boosts and security, custom Ubuntu and Debian builds through Cubic |
| • Issue 1008 (2023-02-27): elementary OS 7.0, the benefits of boot environments, Purism offers lapdock for Librem 5, Ubuntu community flavours directed to drop Flatpak support for Snap |
| • Issue 1007 (2023-02-20): helloSystem 0.8.0, underrated distributions, Solus team working to repair their website, SUSE testing Micro edition, Canonical publishes real-time edition of Ubuntu 22.04 |
| • Issue 1006 (2023-02-13): Playing music with UBports on a PinePhone, quick command line and shell scripting questions, Fedora expands third-party software support, Vanilla OS adds Nix package support |
| • Issue 1005 (2023-02-06): NuTyX 22.12.0 running CDE, user identification numbers, Pop!_OS shares COSMIC progress, Mint makes keyboard and mouse options more accessible |
| • Issue 1004 (2023-01-30): OpenMandriva ROME, checking the health of a disk, Debian adopting OpenSnitch, FreeBSD publishes status report |
| • Issue 1003 (2023-01-23): risiOS 37, mixing package types, Fedora seeks installer feedback, Sparky offers easier persistence with USB writer |
| • Issue 1002 (2023-01-16): Vanilla OS 22.10, Nobara Project 37, verifying torrent downloads, Haiku improvements, HAMMER2 being ports to NetBSD |
| • Issue 1001 (2023-01-09): Arch Linux, Ubuntu tests new system installer, porting KDE software to OpenBSD, verifying files copied properly |
| • Issue 1000 (2023-01-02): Our favourite projects of all time, Fedora trying out unified kernel images and trying to speed up shutdowns, Slackware tests new kernel, detecting what is taking up disk space |
| • Issue 999 (2022-12-19): Favourite distributions of 2022, Fedora plans Budgie spin, UBports releasing security patches for 16.04, Haiku working on new ports |
| • Issue 998 (2022-12-12): OpenBSD 7.2, Asahi Linux enages video hardware acceleration on Apple ARM computers, Manjaro drops proprietary codecs from Mesa package |
| • Issue 997 (2022-12-05): CachyOS 221023 and AgarimOS, working with filenames which contain special characters, elementary OS team fixes delta updates, new features coming to Xfce |
| • Issue 996 (2022-11-28): Void 20221001, remotely shutting down a machine, complex aliases, Fedora tests new web-based installer, Refox OS running on real hardware |
| • Issue 995 (2022-11-21): Fedora 37, swap files vs swap partitions, Unity running on Arch, UBports seeks testers, Murena adds support for more devices |
| • Issue 994 (2022-11-14): Redcore Linux 2201, changing the terminal font size, Fedora plans Phosh spin, openSUSE publishes on-line manual pages, disabling Snap auto-updates |
| • Issue 993 (2022-11-07): Static Linux, working with just a kernel, Mint streamlines Flatpak management, updates coming to elementary OS |
| • Issue 992 (2022-10-31): Lubuntu 22.10, setting permissions on home directories, Linux may drop i486, Fedora delays next version for OpenSSL bug |
| • Issue 991 (2022-10-24): XeroLinux 2022.09, learning who ran sudo, exploring firewall tools, Rolling Rhino Remix gets a fresh start, Fedora plans to revamp live media |
| • Issue 990 (2022-10-17): ravynOS 0.4.0, Lion Linux 3.0, accessing low numbered network ports, Pop!_OS makes progress on COSMIC, Murena launches new phone |
| • Issue 989 (2022-10-10): Ubuntu Unity, kernel bug causes issues with Intel cards, Canonical offers free Ubuntu Pro subscriptions, customizing the command line prompt |
| • Issue 988 (2022-10-03): SpiralLinux 11.220628, finding distros for older equipment and other purposes, SUSE begins releasing ALP prototypes, Debian votes on non-free firmware in installer |
| • Issue 987 (2022-09-26): openSUSE's MicroOS, converting people to using Linux, pfSense updates base system and PHP, Python 2 dropped from Arch |
| • Issue 986 (2022-09-19): Porteus 5.0, remotely wiping a hard drive, a new software centre for Ubuntu, Proxmox offers offline updates |
| • Full list of all issues |
| Star Labs |
Star Labs - Laptops built for Linux.
View our range including the highly anticipated StarFighter. Available with coreboot open-source firmware and a choice of Ubuntu, elementary, Manjaro and more. Visit Star Labs for information, to buy and get support.
|
| Shells.com |
Your own personal Linux computer in the cloud, available on any device. Supported operating systems include Android, Debian, Fedora, KDE neon, Kubuntu, Linux Mint, Manjaro and Ubuntu, ready in minutes.
Starting at US$4.95 per month, 7-day money-back guarantee
|
| Random Distribution | 
ArchStrike
ArchStrike is a distribution for security professionals and researchers based on Arch Linux. ArchStrike provides an extra repository of security software and is available in Openbox and Minimal 64-bit builds. ArchStrike provides a live desktop environment based on the Openbox window manager.
Status: Active
|
| Tips, Tricks, Q&As | | Questions and answers: Creating a live image of the operating system |
| Tips and tricks: Managing multimedia files |
| Questions and answers: Comparing kernel efficiency |
| Tips and tricks: Basename, for loop, dirname, aliases, bash history, xsel clipboard |
| Questions and answers: PCLinuxOS, antiX, and OpenBSD patches |
| Questions and answers: Favourite distributions and tools |
| Tips and tricks: Creating bootable USB drives with UNetbootin |
| Questions and answers: Finding relevant manual pages and merging audio files |
| Tips and tricks: Creating, removing, modifying, and ignoring aliases |
| Tips and tricks: Monitoring and recording user activity |
| More Tips & Tricks and Questions & Answers |
| TUXEDO |
TUXEDO Computers - Linux Hardware in a tailor made suite
Choose from a wide range of laptops and PCs in various sizes and shapes at TUXEDOComputers.com. Every machine comes pre-installed and ready-to-run with Linux. Full 24 months of warranty and lifetime support included!
Learn more about our full service package and all benefits from buying at TUXEDO.
|
| Star Labs |
Star Labs - Laptops built for Linux.
View our range including the highly anticipated StarFighter. Available with coreboot open-source firmware and a choice of Ubuntu, elementary, Manjaro and more. Visit Star Labs for information, to buy and get support.
|
|
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
